Gut

You have 100 trillion roommates and you keep feeding them cardboard.

By

Mr. Jay

Read time

12 minutes

Sections

6

The microbes in your gut outnumber your own cells, produce most of your serotonin, and quietly run a huge chunk of your immune system. We are absolutely starving them.

There is a sentence I keep coming back to from Tim Spector, the British epidemiologist who runs the ZOE project and has spent the last fifteen years studying the human microbiome at scale. The sentence is, roughly, that the average British adult eats fewer than fifteen different plant species in a week, and most of the modern chronic disease epidemic can be traced back to that single number being far too low.

It is one of those facts that, once you absorb it, reorganizes how you think about food. You stop thinking about calories. You stop thinking about macros, mostly. You start thinking about diversity, fiber, fermentation, and feeding the small civilization in your large intestine. Because that small civilization, it turns out, is doing a great deal of the actual work of being alive, and you can either help it or get in its way.

Your gut microbes do not care about your aesthetic preferences. They care about fibre. Almost nobody you know is eating enough fibre. Yes, including you.
01

Meet your microbiome, the organ you did not know you had

Your gut microbiome is the collection of roughly 38 trillion bacteria, fungi, viruses, and other microbes that live in your gastrointestinal tract, mostly in your colon. They outnumber your own human cells roughly one to one, and they contain about 150 times more genes than your human genome. By any reasonable definition, they are an organ. We did not have a name for them until about twenty years ago, because we could not see them or count them, and modern microbiome science is still very early in figuring out what they all do.

What we do know is significant. The microbiome produces an enormous range of metabolites that affect your immune system, your mood, your inflammation levels, your insulin sensitivity, and your brain function. Roughly 90 percent of the body's serotonin is produced in the gut, not the brain. There is a direct neural connection between the gut and the brain via the vagus nerve, which is why anxiety feels like it lives in your stomach. The gut brain axis is not a metaphor. It is anatomy.

When the microbiome is diverse and well fed, it produces short chain fatty acids that nourish the cells of the colon, maintain the integrity of the gut barrier, and reduce systemic inflammation. When it is depleted and starved, the barrier weakens, inflammatory metabolites leak into circulation, and you get the slow burning low grade inflammation that underlies most modern chronic disease. The diet that produces a thriving microbiome and the diet that produces a starved one are not subtle variations of each other. They are categorically different.

Your microbiome is an organ. Treat it like one. You are not allowed to skip feeding it.
02

The thirty plants a week target, and why it is the only food rule worth memorizing

If I could give you one number to focus on, it would be thirty. Thirty different plant species in your weekly diet. This number comes out of the American Gut Project and ZOE research, where Spector and colleagues found that people eating thirty or more distinct plant species per week had significantly more diverse microbiomes than people eating ten or fewer, and that diversity correlated with better metabolic and mental health markers across the board.

Plants count broadly. Fruits, vegetables, legumes, whole grains, nuts, seeds, herbs, and spices all count. A pinch of oregano on your pasta is a plant. A tablespoon of pumpkin seeds on your salad is a plant. A teaspoon of turmeric in your scrambled eggs is a plant. Variety is the entire point because different plants feed different microbial species, and a diverse microbiome is a resilient one.

Most adults I have asked guess that they eat 15 to 20 distinct plant species a week. When they actually write it down for a week, the real number is usually 8 to 12. There is a gap of about 20 species between where they think they are and where they actually are. Closing that gap, even halfway, will measurably change how they feel inside of two months. This is one of the easiest, most enjoyable interventions in all of nutrition, and almost nobody runs it because nobody has handed them the target.

Thirty plant species a week. Count them. The number you write down will be lower than you guess.
03

Fibre is the macronutrient nobody is talking about, and you are catastrophically short on it

The recommended fiber intake for adults is 25 to 38 grams a day, depending on age and sex. The actual average intake in the United States is about 16 grams. That gap is enormous, and it is a quiet driver of most modern gut and metabolic dysfunction. Fiber is not just for going to the bathroom. Fiber is the primary food source for your colonic bacteria. When you do not eat enough of it, they starve, they decline in diversity, and some of them start eating the mucus layer of your gut wall instead, which is exactly as bad as it sounds.

Fiber comes in two broad categories. Soluble fiber, which dissolves in water and ferments into short chain fatty acids in the colon, found in oats, beans, lentils, psyllium, apples, and many vegetables. Insoluble fiber, which adds bulk and speeds transit, found in whole grains, nuts, seeds, and vegetable skins. You want both. A diet built around legumes, whole grains, fruits, and vegetables hits both targets without effort.

If you want to dramatically improve your fiber intake in one week, do this. Add a serving of beans or lentils to one meal a day. Switch white rice for brown rice or barley a couple of times a week. Eat one piece of whole fruit at breakfast. Throw a small handful of nuts and seeds onto your lunch. Add a vegetable side to dinner. That is roughly an extra 15 to 20 grams of fiber a day, and within two weeks your bathroom habits, energy, and hunger patterns will quietly improve.

Average fiber intake is half the target. The gap is the silent driver of most gut complaints.
04

Fermented food is the cheat code we somehow forgot

Almost every traditional cuisine on earth has a fermented food at the center of its daily diet. Kimchi in Korea. Sauerkraut in Germany. Yogurt and kefir across the Middle East and Central Asia. Miso, natto, and pickled vegetables in Japan. Sourdough bread across Europe. Real fermented hot sauces and pickles in the Americas. Then industrial food happened, and most of these disappeared from daily life in favor of shelf stable, pasteurized, dead versions.

The relevant research is a 2021 study from Stanford, led by Justin and Erica Sonnenburg, that compared a high fiber diet to a high fermented food diet over ten weeks in healthy adults. The fermented food group, eating six servings a day of yogurt, kefir, kombucha, kimchi, sauerkraut, and similar foods, showed measurable increases in microbiome diversity and significant decreases in 19 different inflammatory markers. The fiber group did well too, but the fermented food group did dramatically better on inflammation, which surprised the researchers and is reshaping how the field thinks about food and immunity.

You do not need six servings a day to benefit. One or two servings of an actually fermented, live culture product daily, in addition to a fiber rich diet, is a high leverage move. Look for products that say live cultures on the label and are refrigerated. Shelf stable sauerkraut in a jar on the dry goods aisle is pickled, not fermented, and the microbes are dead. Read the label.

One serving of real live fermented food a day. Look for live cultures and the refrigerator section.
05

What is quietly damaging your gut, and the boring things that fix it

There are a small number of common modern habits that damage gut diversity reliably. Ultraprocessed food, particularly products with long ingredient lists full of emulsifiers, artificial sweeteners, and refined oils, reduces microbial diversity in fairly short order. Frequent antibiotic use, particularly broad spectrum antibiotics taken when not strictly necessary, can produce changes in microbiome composition that persist for months or even years. Chronic low grade stress, via the gut brain axis, also alters microbial populations.

On the other side, there are equally boring things that help. A diverse plant heavy diet. Real fermented foods. Adequate sleep, because the microbiome itself runs on a circadian rhythm and is disrupted by erratic sleep. Time spent outdoors in nature, because environmental microbial exposure measurably increases gut diversity. Owning a dog, weirdly, is associated with greater microbiome diversity in the humans in the household, probably because of all the new microbes the dog tracks in.

I am not going to make you afraid of antibiotics, hand sanitizer, or modern hygiene. All of these have saved millions of lives and they remain important. I am going to point out that they have a cost, and the cost is mostly paid in microbial diversity, and the most reasonable response is to use them when needed and to actively rebuild diversity through diet and lifestyle the rest of the time.

Ultraprocessed food, unnecessary antibiotics, and chronic stress are the silent gut destroyers. Diverse plants, fermented food, sleep, and time outside are the silent gut builders.
06

Probiotics are not the answer you think they are

The probiotic supplement industry is enormous. The evidence for most consumer probiotic products is unimpressive. Most strains in most pills either do not survive stomach acid in meaningful numbers, do not colonize the gut once they arrive, or are present in such small quantities relative to your existing microbiome that they have no measurable effect. The exception is in specific clinical situations, particularly recovery from antibiotic associated diarrhea, where certain strains have real evidence behind them.

If you are healthy and you want to support your gut, real fermented food beats almost any probiotic supplement on a per dollar and per effect basis. A serving of live yogurt or kefir contains billions of live organisms in a food matrix that helps them survive digestion. A pill contains a smaller number of strains, often dead by the time you take it, with no food matrix at all. The contest is not close.

If you are recovering from a course of antibiotics, or you are dealing with a specific condition like IBS, the conversation is different and worth having with a clinician who specializes in this area. For general gut health, save your money and buy more vegetables and a tub of plain Greek yogurt instead.

For most healthy adults, real fermented food beats probiotic supplements by a lot.

Your gut is not a side character in your health. It is one of the main organs deciding how you feel, how you think, how you fight off illness, and how you age. Feeding it well is not a complicated science experiment. It is eating a wide variety of plants, including beans and whole grains and fruit and nuts, with one daily contribution of something fermented and alive, and not interrupting that pattern too often with the ultraprocessed stuff. Do that for two months and the part of you that has felt vaguely off for years, the bloating, the energy dips, the brain fog, the irritability, will quietly start to settle. The microbes were waiting. They are still waiting. Feed them.

✦ The five things to remember

  • 01Your microbiome is an organ with 150 times more genes than your human genome.
  • 02Aim for thirty different plant species a week. Count them. The number will surprise you.
  • 03Average fiber intake is roughly half the target. Beans, lentils, whole grains, and fruit close the gap fast.
  • 04One serving of real fermented food a day, with live cultures, has outsized effects on inflammation.
  • 05Most probiotic supplements underperform a daily serving of yogurt, kefir, kimchi, or sauerkraut.

✦ Things people actually ask me

Can I just take fiber supplements?+

Psyllium husk and similar fiber supplements are real and useful, particularly for constipation and cholesterol management. They are not a substitute for the variety of fibers in actual food, which feed different microbial populations. Supplement on top of food, not instead of it.

What about bloating after eating more fiber and beans?+

Expected and temporary. When you suddenly increase fiber and fermentable foods, the gas production from existing microbes ramps up. Over two to four weeks, the microbial population shifts and bloating usually improves significantly. Start slow, drink water, and give it time.

Is gluten actually bad for the gut?+

For people with celiac disease, absolutely yes, completely avoid. For people with diagnosed non celiac gluten sensitivity, often yes. For everyone else, the evidence is weak that whole grain wheat is harmful, and there is real evidence that whole grains are protective against several diseases. The villain in many modern diets is ultraprocessed wheat products, not wheat itself.

About the author

Mr. Jay

Jay writes every word on Health Asylum. No ghostwriters, no AI drafts. He spends an unreasonable amount of time reading peer reviewed research and translating it into plain language for people who do not have time to do the same. Nothing on this site is medical advice. If you have a specific condition, talk to a clinician who knows you.

— end of essayAll essays →